How to Choose Between High ISO and Slow Shutter Speed

When you find yourself caught in low light conditions, do you prefer bumping up the ISO or slowing down the shutter speed? Each of these options has a benefit and a trade off of its own. High ISO introduces more noise in the image, whereas a slower shutter speed causes motion blur to show up. It’s up to you to make the decision for your photo, depending on the situation. Photographer Mark Wallace from Adorama takes up a challenge to evaluate the choices in the following video:

Wallace starts by setting up his Leica M10 with a 28mm lens set at f/8, ISO 100, and 16 seconds. The result is a very pleasing, clean image with beautiful motion blur of the water.

low iso and slow shutter image

Next, he bumps up the ISO to 3200, which changes the shutter speed to 1/2 second. The result? The image looks noisy when viewed at 100 percent, and the water looked better when it was blurry.

high iso and fast shutter speed image

noise due to high iso

The image shows considerable noise when zoomed at 100 percent.

To conclude, if the subject isn’t moving, it’s a better option to shoot at a slower shutter speed and a low ISO.

In cases when it is essential to freeze motion in a low light condition, using a low ISO and a slow shutter speed won’t cut it. You will end up getting a messy image full of motion blur. It thus becomes essential to bump the ISO up in order to have a decent shutter speed. For demonstration, Wallace sets his camera to ISO 6400 at f/2, which lands him up to a shutter speed of 1/60 second for the following image:

handheld shot at high iso

Here is another example where he uses a relatively high ISO:

high iso image

So what did we learn?

“We learned that if we are shooting something that is not moving, like a building or a mountain or maybe even the ocean, and the camera is on a tripod, we can use a very low ISO value and then let that shutter hang for 20–30 seconds or even a few minutes. But for shooting something handheld or walking around in low-light, and we don’t have a flash. . .we need to open up our aperture to let in a lot of light and boost the ISO.”

But then, there is the question of how high you can go with your ISO. Newer generations of cameras are capable of delivering acceptable images even at higher ISOs. Also, be aware that full frame cameras can handle higher ISOs better than APSC or Micro 4/3 cameras. Get to know your camera and see how much can you “exploit” it by cranking up the ISO and evaluating the results.

Like This Article?

Don't Miss The Next One!

Join over 100,000 photographers of all experience levels who receive our free photography tips and articles to stay current: